Château Le Thil Comte Clary 2016
15,5/20
Bettane & Desseauve
92/100
Wine Enthusiast
89-91/100
Robert Parker
93/100
James Suckling
15/20
Le Figaro
" Unusual for the appellation, this wine is 100% Merlot. Smooth and full-bodied on the palate while retaining its elegance, it has tannins that blend well with the juicy black fruit." (Wine Enthusiast) Delivered in a wooden case for orders of 6 bottles of this wine (excluding Pickup Point delivery)
Buy Le Thil wines at the best price in a private sale!
Starting at €99 on your first order
Nose
Notes of dark fruits, blackberries, blueberries, and herbs
Palate
Dense and full-bodied, bursting with dark fruit, robust tannins, lovely minerality, and a long finish featuring notes of plum and blackberry
Serve
Decant at 17-18°C
Drink before
2026
Food and wine pairings
Enjoy it with game birds, red meat, cheese...
Bettane & Desseauve
Wine rated 15.5/20 (Very good wine)
Rated estate (2020 guide) 1*Star (A high-quality, recommendable wine that lives up to what one would expect from its appellation(s))
About the wine:
A very pure, clean, and deep nose, with pronounced notes of blackcurrant, blueberry, and blackberry; the palate is straightforward and full-bodied, with crisp, fresh tannins and a good finish. A wine with character, fresh and lively.
About the estate:
In 2012, Florence and Daniel Cathiard acquired the 12 hectares of Thil Comte Clary, which adjoins their classified growth Smith Haut-Lafitte: three hectares of white wine, divided equally between Sauvignon Blanc and Sémillon, and nearly nine hectares of red wine, with a very high proportion of Merlot. Today, this estate benefits from the expertise of the Smith team. The wines are refined, charming, and perfectly balanced.
Robert Parker - Wine Advocate
Wine rated (2017 guide) 89–91/100 (Excellent wine)
Rated estate (2019 guide) Recommended (Wine producer recommended by Robert Parker - The Wine Advocate)
About the wine:
Château le Thil (Comte Clary) 2016, one of the estates owned by Daniel and Florence Cathiard of Smith Haut Lafitte, is a 100% Merlot this vintage, following the removal of the Cabernet Sauvignon vines to make way for Cabernet Franc. The nose is clean and pure, without excessive intensity, offering aromas of Boysenberry jam and crushed strawberries. The palate is medium-bodied with a lovely mineral opening, a bit masculine and reserved, yet well-balanced. The finish ends on quite elegant notes of blackberry and black plum.[...]
Wine Enthusiast
Wine rated (2017 guide) 92/100
About the wine:
Unusual for this appellation, this wine is 100% Merlot. Smooth and full-bodied on the palate while retaining its elegance, it has tannins that blend well with the juicy black fruit.
James Suckling
Wine rated (2019 guide) 93/100
About the wine:
A lovely freshness with blackberries, blueberries, and herbal notes. Medium-bodied to full-bodied on the palate, rich and dense with a lovely finish. Will need a year or two to open up. A pure Merlot to be enjoyed after 2021.
Le Figaro vins
Wine rated (2017 guide) 15/20
Customer rating
3.3/5
based on 6 reviews
Review by Mr. FREDERIC B. Posted on 12/17/2025
Dark color with a light rim. The nose offers notes of black fruits, such as blueberries and blackberries. The palate is smooth, and the fruit notes linger on the finish.
See all reviews from this customer
Review by Mr. JEAN MICHEL C. Posted on April 15, 2020
He's really not that great
See all reviews from this customer
Review by Mr. ALAIN ANDRE L. Published on July 25, 2024
See all reviews from this customer
Review by Mr. KIM K. Posted on May 19, 2024
See all reviews from this customer
Review by Mr. FRANCOIS P. Posted on April 17, 2021
See all reviews from this customer
Review by Mr. CORENTIN C. Published on May 2, 2020
See all reviews from this customer
Discover more wines from the estate